Good practice

Loi écossaise sur les violences conjugales 2018 — Incrimination du contrôle coercitif en tant que comportement systématique

United Kingdom · Edinburgh · See the United Kingdom profile

Première infraction au RU de «cours de comportement» incriminant le contrôle coercitif comme violence conjugale (Écosse, 2018). Depuis avril 2019 : 93 % des charges en poursuite, condamnations 84–91 % et circonstances aggravantes pour enfant doublées.

93%

Poursuites portées devant les tribunaux (since Apr 2019)

84–91%

Taux de condamnation

Details

Maturity: Established
Promoter: Scottish Government / Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS)
Period: 2018-present
Keywords: domestic abuse, coercive control, gender-based violence, criminal law, legislation

Context

La loi sur les violences domestiques (Écosse) de 2018, en vigueur depuis avril 2019, a créé la première infraction de « ligne de conduite » du Royaume-Uni, érigeant le contrôle coercitif en violence domestique.

Results

Depuis son entrée en vigueur, 93 % des poursuites ont été portées devant les tribunaux, avec des taux de condamnation de 84 à 91 %, et les condamnations avec circonstance aggravante concernant des enfants ont doublé d'une année sur l'autre.

Implementation

Implementation detail (cost, timeline, staffing, conditions for success) is not yet available for this practice.

Data sources

Where this practice's information was retrieved from, and when.

C-NAPSE web research — accessed 2026-06-21
Scottish Government / Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) — accessed 2026-06-21
Scottish Government: Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Act 2018 — Final Reporting Requirement — accessed 2026-06-21
Legislation.gov.uk: Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Act 2018 (primary text) — accessed 2026-06-21
Cairns (2020): The Moorov doctrine and coercive control — Sage Journals / International Journal of Evidence & Proof — accessed 2026-06-21

Quality score: 96/100

How is this calculated?

Evidence: Observational / pre–post

Top 4% in this catalogue (719 scored practices)

Scores cluster high, so position within the catalogue is often more telling than the number alone.

Evaluation

Evaluated by C-NAPSE

Score profile — the dimensions behind the score — how it's computed

Transferability / replicability2/3

England and Wales' Domestic Abuse Act 2021 introduced a coercive control offence partly influenced by the Scottish model; Ireland, Australia and New Zealand have cited the course-of-behaviour approach in their own reform processes.

Impact on gender equality1/1

The Act captured a previously unprosecutable conduct category; 93% of charges proceeded to court and 84-91% conviction rates confirm victims gained meaningful legal protection they previously lacked.

Effectiveness1/1

Proceedings increased 67% in year two; the Act remained the only crime category to rise during COVID-19 court closures — evidence that police and prosecutors adopted the new framework rapidly.

Efficiency1/1

The reform used existing COPFS, police, and sheriff court infrastructure; the main investment was in police and prosecutor training, not new institutions.

Evaluated outcomes1/1

Scottish Government published interim and final reporting-requirement reports; the Scottish Parliament Justice Committee conducted independent post-legislative scrutiny (2022-23); Cairns published peer-reviewed analysis in Sage Journals (2020).

Sustainability1/1

Primary legislation embedded in Scotland's permanent legal system with evolving prosecutorial guidance, Scottish Sentencing Council guidance (2022), and continuing Justice Committee oversight.

Achievement / evidence1/1

383 convictions in 2020-21 alone for a previously un-prosecutable offence category; child aggravation convictions doubled from 39 to 90 — concrete, documented results.

Gender-mainstreaming embedding1/1

The Act explicitly recognises domestic abuse as a gendered crime; statutory guidance acknowledges that the vast majority of perpetrators are male; the course-of-behaviour design addresses patterns of gender-based control structurally.

Curator validation1/1

Scottish Government official criminal justice statistics (gov.scot), legislation.gov.uk primary text, Scottish Parliament committee scrutiny report, and peer-reviewed Sage Journals academic publication — all authoritative independent sources.

Cite this

Evidoria. Loi écossaise sur les violences conjugales 2018 — Incrimination du contrôle coercitif en tant que comportement systématique. Persistent ID: 5ec7fd01-7cf7-42a2-bce3-ae8926c2e0a2.

Export as decision brief (PDF)

Similar practices you may find useful

★ 100

Sweden's Barnahus (Children's House) — Multidisciplinary One-Stop Centres for Child Victims of Sexual Abuse and Violence

Sweden

Sweden's 28 Barnahus co-locate police, social services, prosecution and child psychiatry for child victims of sexual abuse. Evaluations show conviction …

★ 96

Brazil's Maria da Penha Law (Lei 11.340/2006) — Integrated Domestic Violence Protection Framework

Brazil

Lei 11.340/2006 created specialist courts, 48-hour emergency protective orders, and a multi-agency GBV network. IPEA (TD 2048, 2015) found a …

★ 96

Norway's Alternativ til Vold (ATV) — Therapeutic Treatment Programme for Intimate Partner Violence Perpetrators

Norway

Europe's first therapeutic treatment centre for IPV perpetrators (Oslo, 1987), ATV now operates 15 offices in Norway. An NKVTS outcome …

★ 96

Grenelle contre les violences conjugales (France, 2019)

France

France's 2019 Grenelle against domestic violence produced 54 measures; 52 fully implemented. Emergency shelter capacity more than doubled (5,000→11,200+ places), …