Ten island watershed partnerships co-manage 2.6M acres of Hawaiian native forest through fencing and invasive/ungulate removal. ~US$2.5M annual state funding; US$12M leveraged since 2006. UHERO ROI: 593 gal groundwater per dollar invested in fencing (Kaua'i, 50-yr analysis).
2.6 million acres
Native forest watershed under partnership coverage
~2.5 USD million/year
Annual state funding (DLNR)
12 USD million
Private/federal funds leveraged (since 2006)
300,000 acres
Acres managed for ungulates and invasive species (through 2024)
Groundwater recharge return per dollar invested (Kaua'i) (50-year horizon)
21.4 billion gallons
Total groundwater protected (Kaua'i) (50-year horizon)
Details
Maturity
Established
Promoter
Hawai'i Association of Watershed Partnerships (HAWP) / DLNR
Period
2003–present
Keywords
conservation, watershed, invasive species, biodiversity, public sector
Context
The Hawai'i Association of Watershed Partnerships (HAWP), established in 2003, coordinates ten island-based watershed partnerships across five Hawaiian islands, engaging over 100 public agencies, private landowners and NGOs.
Objectives
The partnerships aim to protect more than 2.6 million acres of native forested watershed land - Hawai'i's primary freshwater recharge zone - which collapses when invasive plants or feral ungulates remove forest cover.
Activities
The principal tools are permanent exclusion fencing against feral pigs, goats and deer, followed by intensive invasive plant removal and native seedling outplanting. The State pays for the public-works dimension: DLNR allocates approximately US$2.5 million annually to partnerships, with total private and federal funds leveraged reaching US$12 million since 2006.
Results
Cumulative results through 2024: 300,000 acres managed for ungulates and invasive species, 40+ miles of protective fencing completed, 100,000 native and endangered plants outplanted, and 7,000 community volunteers engaged. Three Mountain Alliance (Maui) protects 3 critically endangered forest birds and 25 endangered plant species across 230,000 acres. East Moloka'i Watershed Partnership completed 11.4 miles of fencing protecting 104 miles of perennial streams. A UHERO peer-reviewed benefit-cost analysis for the Kaua'i Watershed Alliance found that existing fences save 593 gallons of groundwater recharge per dollar invested over a 50-year horizon - equivalent to protecting 21.4 billion gallons of fresh water - with comparable analyses finding approximately 400 gal/$ on Hawai'i Island and 321 gal/$ on Maui.
Conclusions
The cooperative model relies on voluntary participation by private landowners and public agencies rather than legally binding PES contracts. Carbon and biodiversity co-benefits are not independently certified, and governance depends on sustained state appropriations with no formal mechanism if ownership changes.
Implementation
Indicative cost
High (€500k–€5M) — DLNR allocates approximately US$2.5 million annually to the partnerships; total private and federal funds leveraged reached US$12 million since 2006.
Time to results
Long (> 3 years) — HAWP was established in 2003; cumulative accomplishments (fencing, invasive removal, outplanting) are reported through 2024, a 21-year continuous programme.
Staffing & skills
watershed partnership coordinators across 10 island-based partnerships, DLNR technical and funding oversight, community volunteers (7,000 engaged)
Conditions for success
voluntary cooperation among 100+ public agencies, private landowners and NGOs
sustained state appropriations (~US$2.5M/year via DLNR)
permanent exclusion fencing followed by invasive removal and native replanting
active community volunteer engagement
Common failure modes
relies on voluntary participation rather than legally binding PES contracts
no formal mechanism if land ownership changes
carbon and biodiversity co-benefits are not independently certified
governance depends on continued state appropriations
Brazil's first ecological fiscal transfer (1991) redistributes ~R$500 million/year of state VAT revenue to municipalities hosting protected areas or water …