Top 74%
in this catalogue (1194 scored practices)
Scores cluster high, so position within the catalogue is often more telling than the number alone.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
An ex-post cost-benefit evaluation (Hidalgo et al., 2012) monetising travel time, cost, safety and air quality finds results positive and robust, and a World Bank case study reports 32% shorter overall travel time and a 92% fall in accident rates on served corridors, though these are secondary-source figures.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
The trunk-and-feeder BRT model with public planning and private operation has been studied and exported widely, though TransMilenio's own results depend on Bogotá's density and corridor design.
Scalability2/3
The network carries mass ridership, but the authors of the ex-post evaluation note falling user perception and urgent need for service improvements, and expansion requires limiting capital costs.
Sustainability / continuity1/3
Operating contracts and fare collection are separate from planning, which supports continuity, yet the evaluation flags declining service quality and an earlier first-phase study found net-negative results once spillovers on traditional bus users were counted.
Innovation2/3
Bogotá's system adapted Curitiba-style BRT into a high-capacity, closed-corridor, concession-based model that became a global reference.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
No distributional or access analysis was found in the sources reviewed, and perception of service has declined.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration2/3
Combines public planning and regulation by the city with private bus operators under concession, a documented public-private model.
Evidoria. TransMilenio — Bogotá's High-Capacity BRT: A Positive Ex-Post Cost-Benefit Evaluation and Documented Service-Quality Strain. Persistent ID: 8a3e347d-737c-487c-9770-5f1938b5a78a.