evidoria

What works in Sheffield

All catalogues · United Kingdom profile

12
evaluated practices
43/100
average quality score
0%
strong evidence, of 11 assessed

Quality scores are 0–100 rubric scores; “strong evidence” reflects study design; adoptions count documented replications elsewhere. Know more

Evidence snapshot for Sheffield

Sheffield has undertaken two significant urban regeneration initiatives demonstrating creative and environmental approaches to city renewal. Sheffield's Cultural Industries Quarter grew from ~120 cultural businesses and 1,200 jobs in the 1990s to over 2,000 businesses and 9,000 jobs generating almost £1bn annually, diversifying the city's economy after industrial decline. Grey to Green converted a redundant dual carriageway into the UK's largest retrofit sustainable drainage scheme (2014–2022), achieving up to 80% peak flow-rate reduction in storms, diverting ~24,000 bathtubs of water annually from sewers, and increasing measured biodiversity value by nearly 500–561%. Together, these practices show Sheffield's shift from heavy industrial dependency toward creative-sector clustering and climate-adaptive infrastructure, though the evidence does not quantify other dimensions of quality of life or broader social outcomes.

Drawn from: Future Digital Inclusion · Reboot UK · English My Way · Sheffield's Cultural Industries Quarter — Four Decades of Creative-Sector Urban Regeneration · Grey to Green — Sheffield's Retrofit SuDS Scheme Turning a Dual Carriageway into Rain Gardens (UK) · HMCTS - Face-to-face Assisted Digital Support · The Digital Garage · HMRC Work IT Out

Generated from this place's cited practices only. Always check the linked sources.

Strengths & weaknesses vs peers

Strengths

Evidence of impact / measured results +9 pts 67 here · 57 average

Weaknesses

Inclusiveness / equity -9 pts 33 here · 43 average

Governance, certification & transferability -14 pts 50 here · 64 average

Sustainability (ongoing) -18 pts 60 here · 78 average

Demonstrated reach -20 pts 56 here · 76 average

Transferability / demonstrated replication -27 pts 33 here · 60 average

Carbon — sequestration / storage, evidenced -28 pts 0 here · 28 average

Documented learning -30 pts 44 here · 74 average

Evaluation evidence -49 pts 0 here · 49 average

Score profile vs peers

Evidence of impact / measured results
67 · 57
Scalability
67 · 62
Water & soil — retention, infiltration, erosion control
50 · 48
Biodiversity — conservation / improvement, evidenced
50 · 48
Innovation level
61 · 62
Fire resilience — risk reduction, evidenced
0 · 6
Multi-stakeholder collaboration
67 · 74
Inclusiveness / equity
33 · 43
Governance, certification & transferability
50 · 64
Sustainability (ongoing)
60 · 78
Demonstrated reach
56 · 76
Transferability / demonstrated replication
33 · 60
Carbon — sequestration / storage, evidenced
0 · 28
Documented learning
44 · 74
Evaluation evidence
0 · 49

Coloured bar: Sheffield. Grey bar: peer average across the corpus. Both on a common 0–100 scale.

Points compare this place's average on each dimension with the average across all evaluated places, on a common 0–100 scale. Know more

Top good practices here

Future Digital Inclusion · 72

Reboot UK · 72

English My Way · 72

Sheffield's Cultural Industries Quarter — Four Decades of Creative-Sector Urban Regeneration · 62

Grey to Green — Sheffield's Retrofit SuDS Scheme Turning a Dual Carriageway into Rain Gardens (UK) · 53

HMCTS - Face-to-face Assisted Digital Support · 52

The Digital Garage · 32

HMRC Work IT Out · 32

Each number is the practice's overall 0–100 quality score against its catalogue's rubric. Know more

Recommended to adopt or replicate

Transferable practices from elsewhere that address this place's gaps.

Ciudad Mujer — El Salvador's Integrated Women's Services Programme · fit 100/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Already adopted in 3 other places

SASA! Community Mobilisation Programme against Intimate Partner Violence — Uganda · fit 100/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Already adopted in 4 other places

Karya — Fair-Wage AI Data-Work Platform Bringing Digital Income to Rural India · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

safe+natal — Comadrona-Designed Smartphone Checklist for Maternal Risk Screening in Rural Guatemala · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Digital Green — Video-Mediated Agricultural Extension · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Kartu Prakerja – National Digital Skills and Financial Inclusion Programme · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Rwanda's Land Tenure Regularization Programme — Titling Land in Women's Names · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Sweden's Barnahus (Children's House) — Multidisciplinary One-Stop Centres for Child Victims of Sexual Abuse and Violence · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Already adopted in 6 other places

Fit estimates how well a practice matches this place, 0 (poor) to 100 (excellent); the list is ordered to favour practices that address this place's gaps. Know more