evidoria

← Back to browse

Good practice Imported

Oracabessa Bay Fish Sanctuary — Jamaican Fishers' Co-Managed Reef Recovery, 470% Fish Biomass Growth in a Decade

Jamaica · Oracabessa · See the Jamaica profile

Evidence: Observational / pre–post Top 76% 33/100 · Ask Evidence Copilot about this practice

Since 2011, fishers and the GoldenEye Foundation have co-managed a no-take marine sanctuary at Oracabessa Bay, Jamaica. NEPA-monitored herbivorous fish biomass rose from 1,192 g/100m² (2013) to 6,792 g/100m² (2020), alongside coral gardening and sea-turtle protection.

1,192 g/100m²
Herbivorous fish biomass (2013) (2013)
6,792 g/100m²
Herbivorous fish biomass (2020) (2020)
470%
Increase in fish biomass (2013–2020)
~2,500
Coral fragments grown in nurseries
220,000+
Sea-turtle hatchlings released since inception

Details

Maturity
Established
Promoter
Oracabessa Bay Marine Trust / GoldenEye Foundation
Period
2011–present
Keywords
marine conservation, fisheries co-management, coral restoration, coastal tourism

Context

Jamaica's north-coast reefs suffered decades of overfishing and coral decline before a small group of Oracabessa fishers partnered with the GoldenEye Foundation in 2011 to declare a no-take fish sanctuary, now co-managed on a 50/50 fisher–trust board by the Oracabessa Bay Marine Trust.

Objectives

The sanctuary aims to rebuild fish biomass and reef health through no-take protection, coral gardening and sea-turtle conservation, while keeping local fishers as co-managers rather than excluding them.

Activities

Since 2013 the Trust has run a coral gardening programme growing coral fragments in underwater nurseries and out-planting them onto reef-enhancement structures, alongside a sea-turtle hatchery programme, and the co-management model has since been extended to four further north-coast sites with US State Department and GEF/UNDP support.

Results

Jamaica's National Environment and Planning Agency recorded herbivorous fish biomass rising from 1,192 g/100m² in 2013 to 6,792 g/100m² in 2020, roughly a 470% increase, alongside about 2,500 coral fragments grown and 500 out-planted, and more than 220,000 sea-turtle hatchlings released since inception.

Conclusions

Independent reporting cautions the recovery is not risk-free: pollution, microplastics, bleaching and algae overgrowth remain regional pressures, and tension persists between the no-take model and traditional parrotfish harvesting that fishers value even though parrotfish grazing supports reef health.

Implementation

Indicative cost
Low (< €50k) — Supported by a US$17,000 US State Department grant (2019) plus GEF/UNDP funding; no aggregate programme budget given.
Time to results
Long (> 3 years) — Operating continuously since 2011 (sanctuary) and 2013 (reef restoration).
Staffing & skills
Oracabessa fishers (co-managers), GoldenEye Foundation / Oracabessa Bay Marine Trust staff, Tufts University research collaborators

Conditions for success

  • 50/50 fisher–trust co-management board giving fishers a governance stake rather than excluding them
  • Dedicated coral nursery and sea-turtle hatchery infrastructure
  • External grant funding (US State Department, GEF/UNDP) enabling replication to further sites

Common failure modes

  • Regional pressures from pollution, microplastics, bleaching and algae overgrowth
  • Tension between the no-take model and traditional parrotfish harvesting that fishers value for food
  • Physical strain on divers from repeated deep coral-planting dives

Where it fits

Governance type
community co-management (fisher–NGO trust)
Scale
local (single bay, replicated to 4 further sites)
Income level
upper-middle-income

Commonly funded by

Philanthropic / foundation funding National / regional programmes

Indicative funding routes for practices of this type — always check each programme's current calls and eligibility rules.

Do you run this practice? Claim it — verified implementers get a public contact pathway and can propose corrections.

Data sources

Where this practice's information was retrieved from, and when.

Similar practices you may find useful