evidoria

← Back to browse

Good practice Imported

ADA — North Macedonia's Discontinued AI Digital Assistant for Investment and State-Aid Information

North Macedonia · Skopje · See the North Macedonia profile · See the Skopje profile

Evidence: Descriptive / self-reported Top 99% 13/100 · Ask Evidence Copilot about this practice

North Macedonia spent €150,000 on ADA, a trilingual AI investment-info assistant launched April 2023, then let it go dark after two years when it didn't renew the developer's contract — echoing a state audit finding none of 48 AI pilots since 2018 reached production.

~€150,000 (9 million denars)
Project co-financing cost (2023)
0 of 48
AI pilots co-financed 2018-2023 reaching production (2018-2023)
€6.11 million+
Total value of 48 co-financed AI projects (2018-2023)
77th
IMF AI Readiness Index rank (at time of review)
ADA — North Macedonia's Discontinued AI Digital Assistant for Investment and State-Aid Information

Details

Maturity
Discontinued
Promoter
Government of the Republic of North Macedonia / Fund for Innovation and Technological Development (FITD), developed by Codewell Unlimited
Period
April 2023 – 2025 (discontinued after two years)
Keywords
AI chatbot, e-government, investment promotion, public sector AI governance, procurement

Context

In April 2023, North Macedonia's government launched ADA, described as the first AI-based digital assistant in the public sector in the region, to give companies and citizens round-the-clock information — in Macedonian, Albanian and English — about investment conditions and state-aid programmes. The system was developed by Codewell Unlimited and co-financed with roughly 9 million denars (about €150,000) from the Fund for Innovation and Technological Development (FITD).

Results

Two years after launch, ADA went dark: the assistant became non-functional because the government did not extend its contract with the economic operator that had built and maintained it — a routine procurement lapse rather than a technical failure, but with no contingency plan behind it.

Conclusions

ADA's fate mirrors a wider pattern documented by North Macedonia's State Audit Office: between 2018 and 2023 the state co-financed 48 artificial-intelligence projects worth over €6.11 million (via the World Bank and the national budget), and found that none had been implemented in the public sector, attributing this to the absence of a national AI strategy, legal framework, dedicated budget line, or qualified in-house staff — with North Macedonia ranked 77th in the IMF's AI Readiness Index at the time of the review. ADA is included here as a cautionary case: a real, publicly funded citizen-facing AI assistant that launched with genuine multilingual functionality and a working budget, but folded for lack of a continuity plan.

Implementation

Indicative cost
Low (< €50k) — Co-financed with roughly 9 million denars (about €150,000) from the Fund for Innovation and Technological Development (FITD).
Time to results
Medium (1–3 years) — Launched April 2023; went non-functional roughly two years later (c. 2025) when its maintenance contract was not renewed.
Staffing & skills
Codewell Unlimited (developer/economic operator), Fund for Innovation and Technological Development (FITD) — co-financing body

Conditions for success

  • Multilingual functionality (Macedonian, Albanian, English) matching the country's linguistic needs
  • Dedicated co-financing budget line via FITD
  • Contract continuity/succession plan with the maintaining vendor

Common failure modes

  • Government did not renew the maintenance contract with the developer, leaving no contingency plan and causing the assistant to go non-functional after two years
  • Broader national pattern: State Audit Office found none of 48 co-financed AI projects (2018-2023) reached sustained public-sector implementation, attributed to absence of a national AI strategy, legal framework, dedicated budget line, or qualified in-house staff

Where it fits

Governance type
national government fund (FITD) with external vendor
Scale
single national-level citizen-facing assistant
Income level
upper-middle-income, EU candidate country (North Macedonia)

Commonly funded by

National / regional programmes

Indicative funding routes for practices of this type — always check each programme's current calls and eligibility rules.

Do you run this practice? Claim it — verified implementers get a public contact pathway and can propose corrections.

Data sources

Where this practice's information was retrieved from, and when.

Attachments

Similar practices you may find useful