evidoria

← Back to browse

Good practice Imported

North Macedonia's 112 Emergency AI Pilot — Real-Time Call Transcription Stalled by Funding and Legal Gaps

North Macedonia · Skopje · See the North Macedonia profile · See the Skopje profile

Evidence: Observational / pre–post Top 99% 13/100 · Ask Evidence Copilot about this practice

North Macedonia piloted AI to transcribe and flag recommendations in real time on its 112 emergency line, but the State Audit Office found it -- like all 48 AI projects co-financed nationally from 2018-2023 (EUR6.11M) -- never reached full public-sector implementation.

48 projects
AI-related projects co-financed nationally, 2018-2023 (2018-2023)
6.11 EUR million
Combined value of the 48 co-financed AI projects (2018-2023)
5 projects
Projects co-financed solely by the World Bank
5 projects
Projects jointly co-financed by World Bank and state budget
38 projects
Projects financed from the state budget alone
17 sectors
Sectors spanned by the 48 projects
0 projects
AI projects (of 48) reaching public-sector implementation
150000 EUR
Cost of the discontinued ADA digital assistant

Details

Maturity
Discontinued
Promoter
North Macedonia 112 National Emergency Call Centre (reviewed by the State Audit Office)
Period
2018-2023 pilot; State Audit Office review published 2025
Keywords
emergency response, public safety, civil protection, speech AI

Context

North Macedonia's national 112 emergency call centre piloted an artificial-intelligence tool to provide real-time transcription and response recommendations during emergency calls, envisioned as part of a wider drive to modernise civil-protection dispatch.

Objectives

The 112 pilot was one of 48 AI-related projects co-financed in North Macedonia between 2018 and 2023, worth a combined EUR6.11 million, spanning 17 sectors including health, finance, energy, agriculture and public administration.

Activities

Of the 48 projects, 5 were co-financed by the World Bank, 5 jointly by the World Bank and the state budget, and 38 from the state budget alone. A related example cited in the same review is ADA, a EUR150,000 government-funded digital assistant for investment and state-aid information that was discontinued after two years when its maintenance contract was not renewed.

Results

A 2025 State Audit Office review found the 112 pilot's rollout limited by unresolved funding requirements and the absence of a legal and technical framework, with privacy impact assessments for the call data not systematically completed. The Audit Office concluded that none of the 48 co-financed AI projects had been implemented in the public sector.

Conclusions

The Audit Office attributed the pattern to the absence of a national AI strategy or legal framework, inadequate ICT infrastructure, and a shortage of qualified staff — an honest illustration of the gap between pilot funding and production AI in public administration.

Implementation

Indicative cost
Medium (€50k–€500k) — Part of a EUR6.11 million national AI portfolio across 48 projects (2018-2023); no separate budget was disclosed for the 112 pilot itself, so this reflects the average project scale within that portfolio.
Time to results
Medium (1–3 years) — Piloted within the 2018-2023 co-financing window and reviewed by the State Audit Office in 2025; the pilot never progressed beyond testing to full implementation.
Staffing & skills
North Macedonia 112 National Emergency Call Centre, State Audit Office of North Macedonia (reviewer), World Bank (co-financier for some of the 48 projects)

Conditions for success

  • A national AI strategy and legal/technical framework, currently absent per the Audit Office
  • Systematic completion of privacy impact assessments for call data
  • Adequate ICT infrastructure and sufficient qualified staff

Common failure modes

  • Unresolved funding requirements and absence of a legal and technical framework limited the 112 pilot's rollout
  • Privacy impact assessments for call data were not systematically completed
  • None of the 48 co-financed AI projects (2018-2023) reached public-sector implementation
  • The related EUR150,000 ADA assistant was discontinued after two years when its maintenance contract was not renewed
  • Audit Office attributes the pattern to absence of a national AI strategy, inadequate ICT infrastructure and shortage of qualified staff

Commonly funded by

National / regional programmes

Indicative funding routes for practices of this type — always check each programme's current calls and eligibility rules.

Do you run this practice? Claim it — verified implementers get a public contact pathway and can propose corrections.

Data sources

Where this practice's information was retrieved from, and when.

Similar practices you may find useful