Top 61%
neste catálogo (511 práticas pontuadas)
As pontuações concentram-se em valores altos, pelo que a posição dentro do catálogo é muitas vezes mais reveladora do que o número isolado.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
MEF's own 2005 national statistics (801 governments, 30,061 participants, S/.2.6bn) are corroborated by independent World Bank and IEP academic evaluations, though the underlying evidence is observational rather than experimental.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
The law extended a single pioneering municipality's 2000 experiment (Villa El Salvador) into a binding mandate successfully adopted, in some form, by all 26 regions and hundreds of municipalities by 2005.
Scalability3/3
As a national legal mandate it already operates at the largest possible scale for the country, covering regional and local governments engaging tens of thousands of citizens annually.
Sustainability / continuity2/3
The programme has run continuously since 2003, but IEP's 2020 case studies found volatile year-to-year participation and some jurisdictions running it mainly to satisfy the legal requirement.
Innovation2/3
Turning a single-city pilot into a binding national participatory-budgeting law for all subnational governments was a distinctive and internationally studied institutional design choice at the time.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
Independent World Bank and IEP research found women never exceeded about 32% of participants and that poorer, more remote regions had far lower rates of getting citizen-prioritised projects into the actual budget.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration2/3
The process is built around structured collaboration between elected officials, civil-society 'agentes participantes' and technical government teams at every level of government, as documented in MEF's own process design.
Evidoria. Presupuesto Participativo — a Lei Nacional de Orçamento Participativo do Peru. ID persistente: 1d20a32f-d283-4685-889c-939d25da2e5f.