Top 83%
dans ce catalogue (512 pratiques notées)
Les scores se concentrent dans le haut de l’échelle ; la position au sein du catalogue est donc souvent plus parlante que le chiffre seul.
Evidence of impact / measured public value1/3
The often-cited 339-to-115-day improvement is real but reflects DEQ's broader multi-year digitisation (including the 2022 PEEP dashboard), not an isolated, measured result for the AI checklist tool, which is still in proof-of-concept.
Transparency, fairness & accountability1/3
Reporting rests on a single named official's on-record statements to trade press; no accuracy rate, error analysis, vendor name, or underlying model has been publicly disclosed.
Transferability / demonstrated replication1/3
The checklist-comparison approach is conceptually generalisable across DEQ's 124 permit types, but has not been shown to work outside this one agency.
Scalability beyond pilot1/3
Still a proof-of-concept awaiting production approval and explicitly described as a 'foundation' for future work, so scale-up beyond the pilot is not yet demonstrated.
Governance, capability & sustainability2/3
Sits within a sustained, multi-year, publicly documented digital-reform programme (PEEP since 2022) led by a named agency director, indicating institutional continuity even though the AI piece itself is new.
Evidoria. L'assistant IA de checklist du DEQ de Virginie pour l'examen des permis environnementaux. ID persistant: 9154f9a6-4cdd-44fb-880f-c428eaadae19.