Top 61%
en este catálogo (511 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
MEF's own 2005 national statistics (801 governments, 30,061 participants, S/.2.6bn) are corroborated by independent World Bank and IEP academic evaluations, though the underlying evidence is observational rather than experimental.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
The law extended a single pioneering municipality's 2000 experiment (Villa El Salvador) into a binding mandate successfully adopted, in some form, by all 26 regions and hundreds of municipalities by 2005.
Scalability3/3
As a national legal mandate it already operates at the largest possible scale for the country, covering regional and local governments engaging tens of thousands of citizens annually.
Sustainability / continuity2/3
The programme has run continuously since 2003, but IEP's 2020 case studies found volatile year-to-year participation and some jurisdictions running it mainly to satisfy the legal requirement.
Innovation2/3
Turning a single-city pilot into a binding national participatory-budgeting law for all subnational governments was a distinctive and internationally studied institutional design choice at the time.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
Independent World Bank and IEP research found women never exceeded about 32% of participants and that poorer, more remote regions had far lower rates of getting citizen-prioritised projects into the actual budget.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration2/3
The process is built around structured collaboration between elected officials, civil-society 'agentes participantes' and technical government teams at every level of government, as documented in MEF's own process design.
Evidoria. Presupuesto Participativo — la ley nacional peruana de presupuesto participativo. ID persistente: 1d20a32f-d283-4685-889c-939d25da2e5f.