Top 74%
en este catálogo (1194 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
An ex-post cost-benefit evaluation (Hidalgo et al., 2012) monetising travel time, cost, safety and air quality finds results positive and robust, and a World Bank case study reports 32% shorter overall travel time and a 92% fall in accident rates on served corridors, though these are secondary-source figures.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
The trunk-and-feeder BRT model with public planning and private operation has been studied and exported widely, though TransMilenio's own results depend on Bogotá's density and corridor design.
Scalability2/3
The network carries mass ridership, but the authors of the ex-post evaluation note falling user perception and urgent need for service improvements, and expansion requires limiting capital costs.
Sustainability / continuity1/3
Operating contracts and fare collection are separate from planning, which supports continuity, yet the evaluation flags declining service quality and an earlier first-phase study found net-negative results once spillovers on traditional bus users were counted.
Innovation2/3
Bogotá's system adapted Curitiba-style BRT into a high-capacity, closed-corridor, concession-based model that became a global reference.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
No distributional or access analysis was found in the sources reviewed, and perception of service has declined.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration2/3
Combines public planning and regulation by the city with private bus operators under concession, a documented public-private model.
Evidoria. TransMilenio — El BRT de alta capacidad de Bogotá: evaluación coste-beneficio ex post positiva y tensión documentada en la calidad del servicio. ID persistente: 8a3e347d-737c-487c-9770-5f1938b5a78a.