Top 83%
en este catálogo (512 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured public value1/3
The often-cited 339-to-115-day improvement is real but reflects DEQ's broader multi-year digitisation (including the 2022 PEEP dashboard), not an isolated, measured result for the AI checklist tool, which is still in proof-of-concept.
Transparency, fairness & accountability1/3
Reporting rests on a single named official's on-record statements to trade press; no accuracy rate, error analysis, vendor name, or underlying model has been publicly disclosed.
Transferability / demonstrated replication1/3
The checklist-comparison approach is conceptually generalisable across DEQ's 124 permit types, but has not been shown to work outside this one agency.
Scalability beyond pilot1/3
Still a proof-of-concept awaiting production approval and explicitly described as a 'foundation' for future work, so scale-up beyond the pilot is not yet demonstrated.
Governance, capability & sustainability2/3
Sits within a sustained, multi-year, publicly documented digital-reform programme (PEEP since 2022) led by a named agency director, indicating institutional continuity even though the AI piece itself is new.
Evidoria. El asistente de IA de listas de verificación del DEQ de Virginia para la revisión de permisos ambientales. ID persistente: 9154f9a6-4cdd-44fb-880f-c428eaadae19.