Top 83%
dans ce catalogue (1137 pratiques notées)
Les scores se concentrent dans le haut de l’échelle ; la position au sein du catalogue est donc souvent plus parlante que le chiffre seul.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
Council monitoring shows NO2 17% below 2019 and 37% below 2016 with compliance rising from 15.2% to 6.0%, but without an independent counterfactual and with baseline-dependent headlines.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
As a Class D zone with published monitoring methods it is a usable reference for other English cities, although this entry cites no documented replication elsewhere.
Scalability2/3
The zone operates across the whole city-centre ring with roughly 100,000 unique vehicle entries per day, but expansion beyond the zone is not shown.
Sustainability / continuity2/3
The scheme has operated since June 2021 with annual reporting, though two areas inside the zone remain over the legal limit and improvement may be slowing.
Innovation1/3
Class D charging zones are a standard national policy tool, so the innovation lies in implementation rather than in a new mechanism.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
The sources reviewed do not report effects on lower-income drivers or small businesses, so equity impact is unevidenced.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration1/3
The scheme is council-led under a national framework, and the sources describe little structured multi-stakeholder governance.
Evidoria. Zone à air pur de Birmingham (2021) — Zone payante de classe D avec un NO2 en baisse de 37 % par rapport à 2016 mais de 17 % seulement par rapport à 2019, et des dépassements persistants. ID persistant: 68c718bf-ef61-4738-b85f-83bcd7fce4b1.