evidoria

What works in Astana

All catalogues · Kazakhstan profile

17
evaluated practices
56/100
average quality score
0%
strong evidence, of 16 assessed
1
adoptions elsewhere
{# KAN-370: every section closes with a one-line "what is this number" note + Know more. The note only names metrics actually shown — the strong-evidence tile hides when nothing is assessed (KAN-364 honesty rule), so its mention hides with it. #}

Quality scores are 0–100 rubric scores; “strong evidence” reflects study design; adoptions count documented replications elsewhere. Know more

Evidence snapshot for Astana

Astana is home to Astana Hub, Kazakhstan's government-backed international technopark for IT startups, which by end-2024 had grown to 1,600 registered resident companies (including 425+ with foreign participation) that generated $1.3 billion in total revenue, $481.5 million in IT-service exports, and attracted $177 million in investment, while creating 28,000 new tech-sector jobs since inception. The city also hosts courts that participated in Kazakhstan's AI case-outcome analytics pilot, where settlement rates reportedly exceeded the national average once parties could access precedent before hearings. Additionally, Astana is the location where Nazarbayev University's NURIS Innovation Cluster is partnering with UNICEF to develop open-source AI resources for education.

Drawn from: Astana Hub — International Technopark of IT Start-ups · Digital Analytics of Judicial Practice — Kazakhstan's AI Case-Outcome Tool, Scaled to Every Court · Orleu / UNESCO-IITE National Generative-AI Micro-Certification for Teachers (Kazakhstan) · Kazakhstan National AI in Education Standards 2025–2029 · Digital Family Card — Kazakhstan's AI-driven proactive social protection targeting · Digital Kazakhstan: Digital Literacy & E-Government Access Programme · Smart Data Finance — Kazakhstan's AI Platform for Unified Taxpayer Profiles and Shadow-Economy Detection · Astana Hub — Kazakhstan's Tax-Free Technopark for Scaling Tech Companies

Generated from this place's cited practices only. Always check the linked sources.

Strengths & weaknesses vs peers

{# KAN-369 chips show whole points; the explanation lives in the section's bottom note (KAN-370) so each concept is explained exactly once. #}

Strengths

Evaluation evidence +64 pts 100 here · 36 average

Documented learning +27 pts 100 here · 73 average

Demonstrated reach +25 pts 100 here · 75 average

Transparency, ethics & data protection +17 pts 67 here · 50 average

Scalability beyond pilot +16 pts 82 here · 66 average

Teacher capability & pedagogy +11 pts 50 here · 39 average

Weaknesses

Fire resilience — risk reduction, evidenced -9 pts 0 here · 9 average

Innovation -13 pts 52 here · 64 average

Governance, capability & sustainability -14 pts 52 here · 66 average

Water & soil — retention, infiltration, erosion control -18 pts 33 here · 51 average

Biodiversity — conservation / improvement, evidenced -20 pts 33 here · 53 average

Multi-stakeholder collaboration -23 pts 56 here · 78 average

Curator validation -25 pts 50 here · 75 average

Inclusiveness / equity -30 pts 11 here · 41 average

Effectiveness -31 pts 50 here · 81 average

Evaluated outcomes -34 pts 50 here · 84 average

Gender-mainstreaming embedding -40 pts 50 here · 90 average

Achievement / evidence -43 pts 50 here · 93 average

Efficiency -52 pts 0 here · 52 average

Impact on gender equality -83 pts 0 here · 83 average

{# Score profile vs peers (KAN-364, UX2.3): every dimension as place-vs-corpus bars — the full picture behind the strengths/weaknesses shortlists above. #}

Score profile vs peers

Evaluation evidence
100 · 36
Documented learning
100 · 73
Demonstrated reach
100 · 75
Transparency, ethics & data protection
67 · 50
Scalability beyond pilot
82 · 66
Teacher capability & pedagogy
50 · 39
Equity & inclusion
58 · 54
Evidence of learning impact
33 · 30
Evidence of impact / measured public value
59 · 60
Carbon — sequestration / storage, evidenced
33 · 35
Transparency, fairness & accountability
50 · 54
Transferability / demonstrated replication
55 · 59
Sustainability
72 · 80
Fire resilience — risk reduction, evidenced
0 · 9
Innovation
52 · 64
Governance, capability & sustainability
52 · 66
Water & soil — retention, infiltration, erosion control
33 · 51
Biodiversity — conservation / improvement, evidenced
33 · 53
Multi-stakeholder collaboration
56 · 78
Curator validation
50 · 75
Inclusiveness / equity
11 · 41
Effectiveness
50 · 81
Evaluated outcomes
50 · 84
Gender-mainstreaming embedding
50 · 90
Achievement / evidence
50 · 93
Efficiency
0 · 52
Impact on gender equality
0 · 83

Coloured bar: Astana. Grey bar: peer average across the corpus. Both on a common 0–100 scale.

Points compare this place's average on each dimension with the average across all evaluated places, on a common 0–100 scale. Know more

Top good practices here

Astana Hub — International Technopark of IT Start-ups · 76

Digital Analytics of Judicial Practice — Kazakhstan's AI Case-Outcome Tool, Scaled to Every Court · 73

Orleu / UNESCO-IITE National Generative-AI Micro-Certification for Teachers (Kazakhstan) · 73

Kazakhstan National AI in Education Standards 2025–2029 · 73

Digital Family Card — Kazakhstan's AI-driven proactive social protection targeting · 73

Digital Kazakhstan: Digital Literacy & E-Government Access Programme · 68

Smart Data Finance — Kazakhstan's AI Platform for Unified Taxpayer Profiles and Shadow-Economy Detection · 67

Astana Hub — Kazakhstan's Tax-Free Technopark for Scaling Tech Companies · 67

Each number is the practice's overall 0–100 quality score against its catalogue's rubric. Know more

Recommended to adopt or replicate

Transferable practices from elsewhere that address this place's gaps.

{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Ciudad Mujer — El Salvador's Integrated Women's Services Programme · fit 100/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

SASA! Community Mobilisation Programme against Intimate Partner Violence — Uganda · fit 100/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Digital Green — Video-Mediated Agricultural Extension · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Kartu Prakerja – National Digital Skills and Financial Inclusion Programme · fit 100/100

  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Rwanda's Land Tenure Regularization Programme — Titling Land in Women's Names · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Sweden's Barnahus (Children's House) — Multidisciplinary One-Stop Centres for Child Victims of Sexual Abuse and Violence · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Stadtidee Aarau — Switzerland's First City-Wide Participatory Budget Using the Method of Equal Shares · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions
{# KAN-369: display the true 0–100 fit (rec.score) — gap_score is ordering-only and exceeds 100 by construction; the weak-gap boost surfaces as a reason line instead. #}

Copenhagen Business Hub (Erhvervshus Hovedstaden) · fit 90/100

  • Rated highly transferable
  • Backed by strong evidence
  • Addresses this place's weak dimensions

Fit estimates how well a practice matches this place, 0 (poor) to 100 (excellent); the list is ordered to favour practices that address this place's gaps. Know more