Top 16%
neste catálogo (246 práticas pontuadas)
As pontuações concentram-se em valores altos, pelo que a posição dentro do catálogo é muitas vezes mais reveladora do que o número isolado.
Evidence of impact / measured public value2/3
UNDP implementation partner reports 5.9 million families mapped, 2.2 million social services proactively delivered since 2023, and 263,000 proactive benefit recipients in 2024; outcomes independently recognised by the 2024 GovTech Prize at the World Government Summit.
Transparency, fairness & accountability2/3
Citizens consent via SMS before benefit activation, and five well-being criteria plus indicator count are publicly disclosed; however, no independent algorithmic audit or demographic bias assessment has been published, capping this score.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
UNDP is promoting the model at international forums (Asia-Pacific Conference 2024) and replication feasibility is under assessment; no confirmed second-country deployment documented yet.
Scalability beyond pilot3/3
Deployed at full national scale from January 2023, covering all 5.9 million Kazakhstani households across 17 regions — well beyond pilot stage.
Governance, capability & sustainability2/3
Multi-agency coordination across 20+ government bodies with Ministry of Labour oversight and UNDP implementation support; no formal independent appeals mechanism or published algorithmic impact assessment limits the score to 2.
Evidoria. Cartão Digital da Família — Sistema cazaque de proteção social proativa baseado em IA. ID persistente: bdb837be-5fc2-44c6-b140-6fe1937d8567.