Top 74%
en este catálogo (1041 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured public value2/3
Two independent outlets corroborate concrete usage figures (150,000+ uses in four months, 2 million-plus Q1 requests, 30% drop in in-person visits) from named officials, though the figures are self-reported by government and not independently audited.
Transparency, fairness & accountability1/3
Officials publicly disclosed scope (50 services, ~30% of requests) and an explicit advisory-only boundary for sensitive decisions, but no accuracy, error-rate, or bias audit has been published.
Transferability / demonstrated replication1/3
The assistant runs on Kazakhstan's own sovereign infrastructure (national supercomputer, AlemLLM), so replicating it elsewhere requires comparable domestic infrastructure investment, not just the concept.
Scalability beyond pilot2/3
Government has a stated, funded roadmap to expand from 50 to roughly 200 services and from 30% to 70% of citizen-request coverage within the same year, backed by already-large usage volumes.
Governance, capability & sustainability1/3
A deliberate design choice keeps the AI advisory-only for benefit eligibility, with humans retaining final decisions, but there is no published independent oversight, appeals mechanism, or audit of the system.
Evidoria. eGov GPT — el Asistente Conversacional de IA de Kazajistán Reduce un 30% las Visitas Presenciales a los Centros de Servicio. ID persistente: e411324c-4a81-4b80-b57e-c5328ea1b9cd.