Top 83%
en este catálogo (1071 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured results1/3
The single rigorous, peer-reviewed RCT (Hanna, Olken et al., forthcoming American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2025, 20 lotteries covering 11M+ applicants) found no detectable impact on employment or consumption, contradicting earlier unpublished 'preliminary' figures still used in promotional material.
Transferability / demonstrated replication1/3
Cited in academic literature as a reference case for active labour-market policy design, but no confirmed direct replication of the model in another country was found, and its own rigorous evaluation found no measurable effect to replicate.
Scalability3/3
Reached roughly 18.9-19 million beneficiaries across all 34 provinces and 514 districts/cities by late 2024, with Rp41.59 trillion (~US$2.66bn) in cumulative incentives disbursed — among the largest active labour-market programmes evaluated anywhere.
Sustainability / continuity2/3
Still running as of 2024, but confirmed annual budgets fell from Rp17.99 trillion (2022) to about Rp5 trillion (2024) and the 2024 beneficiary target dropped to roughly 1.15 million, with a planned 2025 wave delayed amid a management transfer to the Ministry of Manpower.
Innovation2/3
Paired a digital training-voucher marketplace with direct post-training cash incentives, a design run at national scale that generated one of the largest labour-market RCTs conducted anywhere.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
Uses a provincial quota system intended to spread access beyond Java, but requires smartphone/internet-based registration that multiple independent analyses say structurally disadvantages informal-sector and rural workers.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration1/3
Delivered through a marketplace of private digital-training platforms working with government, but in 2020 the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) found conflicts of interest at 5 of 8 partner platforms, and two presidential special staffers resigned over related conflicts.
Evidoria. Kartu Prakerja — la Tarjeta de Preempleo de Indonesia. ID persistente: d66f78f3-5a00-47c0-a9c6-8076fb74e8dd.