Top 83%
en este catálogo (1192 prácticas puntuadas)
Las puntuaciones se concentran en valores altos, por lo que la posición dentro del catálogo suele ser más reveladora que el número por sí solo.
Evidence of impact / measured results2/3
Council monitoring shows NO2 17% below 2019 and 37% below 2016 with compliance rising from 15.2% to 6.0%, but without an independent counterfactual and with baseline-dependent headlines.
Transferability / demonstrated replication2/3
As a Class D zone with published monitoring methods it is a usable reference for other English cities, although this entry cites no documented replication elsewhere.
Scalability2/3
The zone operates across the whole city-centre ring with roughly 100,000 unique vehicle entries per day, but expansion beyond the zone is not shown.
Sustainability / continuity2/3
The scheme has operated since June 2021 with annual reporting, though two areas inside the zone remain over the legal limit and improvement may be slowing.
Innovation1/3
Class D charging zones are a standard national policy tool, so the innovation lies in implementation rather than in a new mechanism.
Inclusiveness / equity1/3
The sources reviewed do not report effects on lower-income drivers or small businesses, so equity impact is unevidenced.
Multi-stakeholder collaboration1/3
The scheme is council-led under a national framework, and the sources describe little structured multi-stakeholder governance.
Evidoria. Zona de Aire Limpio de Birmingham (2021) — Zona de pago de clase D con el NO2 un 37 % por debajo de 2016 pero solo un 17 % respecto a 2019, y superaciones que persisten. ID persistente: 68c718bf-ef61-4738-b85f-83bcd7fce4b1.